Why believe in a god?

whybelieveDuring my recent DC trip I came across an interesting ad campaign.  There were posters on the Metro train that asked the question, “Why believe in a god? Just be good for goodness sake.”  I couldn’t wait to find out more about what was going on here.  I’ve blogged a bit before about the idea of atheists starting to “evangelize,” for lack of a better term.

After I got home I looked up their website (whybelieveinagod.org).  Turns out this is an ad campaign put out by Free Thought Action and the DC Area Secular Humanists.


Both of these  organizations cast themselves more as humanists than atheists or agnostics.  Not that they shy from those terms, they just seem to avoid those labels, which is probably a good idea and more accurate.  Regardless of their level of disbelief, it’s fair to say they put human logic and knowledge above faith in their “belief system.”

What I found most interesting is the focus on logic as a defining characteristic.  Free Thought Action chose their name with reason when they say, “We hope you’ll join us to promote eyes-wide-open facts, not blind faith, as the foundation of our society.”

The implication here is that humanism uses reason, facts, and science to come to its conclusions, while religion is more naive and close-minded.

On the one hand this characterization bugs me.  I can’t speak for the other religions they speak of , but I think Christianity is miscast too much as a foolish, non-thinking system of belief.  Faith is not the absence of all doubt; it’s not just “believing in what you can’t see.” It’s belief based on what we do know, and being willing to take the next step into we can not be sure of.  In that way I think it is actually more intellectually honest than humanism in many ways.

But I can’t help but wonder if we (christians) have painted ourselves into this corner.  By fighting against culture and society and refusing to engage, we come off bull-headed, foolish, and weak.  When we are too quick to lash out and defend, it makes us look afraid.

I think we may have asked for people to assume we don’t know what we’re talking about.

If  God is so defenseless, if culture is so scary, if our religion is on the verge of disaster at every turn . . . why believe in a god?

I know I don’t want to believe in that God.


3 Responses

  1. Sadly, we Christians do come across as weak and foolish or bullheaded and judgmental. We are grossly ignorant of why we believe and what we believe. Too many times, the answer is “Because the Bible says so!”

    While that may be an adequate response to those who actually read and study scripture, it is inadequate for those who have only scanned the Bible and take most verses out of context (if they have indeed read it at all).

    I find it extremely ironic that logic and reason really leave no other conclusion than we are the products of an Intelligent Designer (God), rather than some byproduct of random chance that came from nothing!

    The problem is that to acknowledge that we were created, not evolved from primordial ooze, is to then realize that we
    just might have to answer to some higher power. And that scares the dickens out of the secular humanists and atheists because then they would have to give up their god of pleasure or hedonism.

  2. Good points. I agree that careful consideration does lead us to a Creator.
    I think you sort of hit on something there, too. Even if we feel we can “argue” our point, usually that’s not the point. It just traps us in an argument. There are often underlying causes or roots behind disbelief in my experience. That’s why it’s so important to know people for who they are, not just fight against their beliefs.
    I would be careful about assuming atheists are by nature hedonistic. Probably their best argument is the abundance of moral, good non-believers.

  3. Thanks for the admonition about assuming atheists are hedonistic. I was not being fair or open-minded. Grace and Peace.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: